When you’re handed a lemon – make lemonade. The PNG Oil Search shares saga.

By PNG Echo.

Prime Minister Peter O'Neill has hit back at critics
Prime Minister Peter O’Neill has hit back at critics

Prime Minister, Peter O’Neill has defended his government’s position on the controversial UBS loan in the wake of an article published by Fairfax Media saying:

The cost of losses we suffered to the Arabs are far worse than the cost we pay on the loan from UBS.”

He went on to explain:

PNG paid $8.20 when the Somare government agreed to pay $8.50 to the Arabs, Oil Search is our country’s biggest tax payer and one of the largest employers of our citizens so why is it wrong for us to be a stable shareholder in that company?

In reality, this is a question that only time will answer – but the other often overlooked reality is that it was a decision that was forced upon the Prime Minister by the actions of a previous government – that of the Somare government and its Minister Arthur Somare and the disastrous deal with Arab money.

While it is true that there was more than one solution to the situation forced upon this government, it is also true that given the current state of the market, it is moot whether any alternative would have yielded a better result.

The Deal

UBS-small-business-loan-fundReading the information provided in the aforementioned article (written by John Garnaut – son of Ross Garnaut an erstwhile Chairman of the PNGSDP and someone that the Prime Minister declared “unwelcome” to return to PNG) the deal has its weaknesses but it also has its strengths.

Being given that its weaknesses have already been amply explored and exaggerated  – let’s now consider it’s strengths.

Garnaut describes a situation whereby 20-30 of the best financial minds worked 24/7 for two weeks to create a deal that was a win-win-win situation: for PNG, for Oil Search and for UBS.   It was acknowledged that no one else could have offered PNG a deal on better terms than UBS.

And sometimes even the perceived “weaknesses” turned out to be strengths when the much criticised ‘collar arrangement’ according to Garnaut:

… rescued the PNG government from the full force of the unexpected fall in prices for oil, gas and Oil Search. A plain vanilla loan would have left them in worse shape.

A UBS spokeswoman explained:

Given the recent weakness in the oil price, this protection has clearly been shown to be valuable for the PNG government.

The Lawyers get involved

It is difficult to discern, from the article, whether Garnaut is suggesting the UBS loan is a sweetheart deal for the bank to the detriment of PNG or whether he’s saying the opposite.

He quotes Robert Wyld, co-chair of the International Bar Association who questions why UBS would contemplate such a deal, saying:

Where is the commercial logic? You would think that anybody at the highest levels at UBS would have known they were dealing with an incredibly high-risk government with an incredibly high-risk prime minister.

Lawyer Greg Egan - banned from entering PNG because of alleged visa irregularities
Lawyer Greg Egan – banned from entering PNG because of alleged visa irregularities

But while the International Bar Association may have this poor opinion of dealing with Papua New Guinea, conversely, the Australian Bar Association was at odds to make sure its members are able to continue to tap this lucrative market – and when lawyers Greg Egan and Terry Lambert were banned from entering the country because of alleged visa irregularities, they had this to say:

Foreign counsels play an important role in the administration of justice in PNG and lawyers must be allowed to practise without intimidation. This includes the right of entry into the country.

It’s clear to see where the “commercial logic” is there.

Australian interests:

That this issue has received so many column inches in Australian newspapers, newspapers that are routinely uninterested in matters to do with the Papua New Guinea, is summed up by two sentences of Garnaut’s:

UBS struck a massively controversial deal to land the PNG government with a 10 per cent stake in ASX and PNG-listed company Oil Search. Those shares are seen now as an effective blocking stake to Woodside’s ambitions to buy Oil Search, in one of the biggest deals currently in play.

woodside-1977The deal has established Papua New Guinea as a major corporate player in the Australian Market.

It’s to do with Australian corporate profits and the thwarted Woodside attempted takeover of Oil Search. It is well-recognised that Papua New Guinea could be a considerable deal breaker here even though the Prime Minister has indicated that he will consider the proposals on their merit and will not arbitrarily block any well-negotiated and reasonable deal.

Hail the lukewarm patriots

Nevertheless, what is surprising about the commentary I have read on Garnaut’s article is that the PNG commentators have chosen to accentuate and accept all that is negative in this report while ignoring the positive. No one has asked why Australia is all of a sudden so interested in PNG politics or why it is this particular deal on which they’re focussed? Everyone has just accepted the Australian line.

Some PNG commentators (of the noisier variety) have employed wildly defamatory and unsubstantiated accusations against both Prime Minister Peter O’Neill and Oil Search’s Peter Botten that involve alleged massive kickbacks and insider trading. This is almost as unconscionable as their resort to racism and Prime Minister O’Neill’s Irish heritage.

Think about it PNG – this is all smacks of Australian vested interest.

Collectively, Australians will always have the welfare of Australia prominent in their psyches and in their actions. They don’t want PNG to impact on Australian corporate deals while being very willing to take advantage of the lucrative market for Australians in PNG – like visiting lawyers.

Panguna mine on Bougainville - the catalyst to a civil war
Panguna mine on Bougainville – the catalyst to a civil war

And don’t get me started on the article that warns that tribal chiefs are threatening civil war over the UBS loan – just like on Bougainville. There are so many gaps in the argument that this is a similar situation to Bougainville that whole national parks can be ranged in those gaps.

The whole article is exploitative, irresponsible and screams “vested interests”.
But ultimately, what’s completely risible about the situation is that:

…the land owner claims are being supported by Arthur Somare, who led the 2009 negotiations, and who is the son of Sir Michael Somare, who recently referred Mr O’Neill to a leadership misconduct tribunal.

Arthur Somare is also the man who struck the deal with Arabs that led to the situation and the decision to do the deal with UBS that the landowners are railing against.

His government's deal, his son's actions.
His government’s deal, his son’s actions.

In a similar irony, Sir Michael Somare  who was Prime Minister in the government that set up the original loan under son and Government Minister Arthur and who has recently resigned from the party he formed – the National Alliance (after being asked to step down) has come out saying:

We are calling on our Prime Minister Peter O’Neill to explain to the nation why he has saddled Papua New Guinea with a huge financial burden with the UBS-Oil Search loan which is aggravating the government in simmering fiscal crisis.

Do neither of the Somare’s recognise the irony of their positions, not to mention the sheer bloody hypocrisy?

Share Button

8 thoughts on “When you’re handed a lemon – make lemonade. The PNG Oil Search shares saga.

  1. Thank you Dr Susan Merrell for the master piece from another angle. You are such a tough lady. You cop shits left right centre from the social media in this country, PNG, and im sure you cop too many stray emails with bad taste too, but dont know where you get the strength to stand up and speak. You are true lady made of steel and brick. Certainly admire your skills of adversity.
    Anyway to the point, pleased to get a glimpse of an Australian vested interest from an Aistralian citizens honest perspective. We have been bombarded with the negative side of the UBS deal and thought it was a worse evil but we can now see that however bad the deal may seem, our PM was pushed to the corner. Given the circumstances he did the correct thing in saving Oil Search as OS was a corporate citizen of PNG. The fault of the Somare Regime with his academically flopped son Arthur at the helm instigated the initial Mayhem for the LNG worse gas deal. Thanks Susan.
    Please refer to me as Ikae PisOdolopin

  2. This is a much bettet article that deserves credit. Much better than others that lack insight and objectivity. Please maintain your blog or article in such a manner and you’d draw more interest to appreciate your effort. Good insight…. Well done!

      • I personally would like to see more investigative reporting from our own domestic journalists. There are so many questions which remain unanswered. For example:
        1. regardless of the intricasies of the USB deal does the loan from UBS for US$1.2b equate to the amount of shares purchased supposedly by the PNG Govt? If not and if there is a shortfall, where has the balance of the funds under the loan gone to and more importantly who stands to benefit from these funds?
        2. Why did Peter O’Neil decide to buy a 10 percent stake in Oil Search for the Elk Antelope Project as opposed to taking up the State’s option of 22.5 percent stake in the project?
        These queries coupled with the great lengths O’Neil has taken to avoid answering queries under Oath in a Court or Tribunal can only leave ordinary citizens questioning O’Neils credibility.
        It also doesn’t help when he galavants around the world and PNG in the same Falcon Jet he was critical of the previous government for purchasing and promised to sell the same once he got into power back in 2012.

  3. Great stuff and its good to read this from a different angle. Always refreshing to read your articles in this blog. Cheers. Ben

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *